What Pokémon Cards Do Collectors Actually Keep? We Asked 142 of Them
Every day, Holobrook shows three real slabs and asks you to keep one, sell one and donate one. Two weeks in, the votes are starting to say something.
The Holobrook Gazette ·
Mega Latias ex · PSA 9 · kept by 72%
Charizard ex · BGS 10 · kept by 67%
Pikachu ex · BGS 9.5 · donated by 45%Price guides tell you what a card is worth. They can't tell you which cards people would actually keep if they had to choose. So we made them choose.
Our daily game, Keep, Sell or Donate, puts three graded slabs on the table. You keep one, sell one and donate one. No skipping, no keeping all three. Since November 1, 142 collectors have cast 333 counted ballots, which works out to 999 judgments on real slabs.
Which Pokémon cards are worth keeping, according to the town
The clearest winner was Mega Latias ex in a PSA 9. Twenty-three of 32 voters kept it and only two would give it away. Close behind was a Charizard ex promo in a BGS 10, kept by two out of three voters, which is about what you'd expect for a perfect Charizard.
Then it gets interesting. The same Charizard ex in a BGS 7.5 was kept by just 6 of 29 voters. Same Pokémon, same card, a lower grade, and suddenly most people would rather sell it. Even Charizard needs a good grade.
The biggest surprise was Pikachu ex from Prismatic Evolutions, the gold Hyper Rare, in a BGS 9.5. It's a card that sells for hundreds in a top grade, and 13 of 29 voters gave it away. Our best guess: next to a Pokémon people love more, a gold Pikachu makes a great gift for a newer collector.
Value matters, but less than you'd think
Expensive slabs do get kept more often. Cards worth $50 or more were kept 47% of the time; cards under $10 were kept 28% of the time and donated 39%. Still, more than half of the town's $50+ slabs got sold or donated. Money alone doesn't decide it.
Grade mattered less than price. A gem mint 10 was kept 40% of the time, a 9 or 9.5 was kept 35%, and anything below 9 was kept 28%. A perfect grade nudges people, but it can't rescue a card nobody's attached to: a PSA 10 Heliolisk was kept by 1 voter out of 28.
So should you keep or sell your cards?
If the town is any guide: keep the ones you'd miss. The most-kept cards weren't the priciest. They were Pokémon people grew up with or chase on purpose, like Latias, Charizard, Eevee and Mewtwo. Sell the slab you only like for its number, and give away the one that would make a newer collector's week.
The vote resets every day. Cast today's on Holobrook; the results show up the next morning.